Hidden Cities

Stories from the Middle East

CNN explains the Islamic Revolution

I first saw this on the Angry Arab. CNN International is only marginally different than CNN in the States, and I’ve seen plenty of coverage of the Shah’s family here. As the last Shah’s exiled son said in DC on Monday, “The moment of truth has arrived… The people of Iran need to know who stands with them.” Indeed. Then CNN decides to explain how the man got to America.

Pahlavi has lived in exile since 1979, when his father, Mohammad Reza Shah Pahlavi, was overthrown during the Islamic Revolution. Under the shah’s regime, Iran saw nationalization of its oil and a strong movement toward modernization. Still, his secular programs and recognition of Israel cost him the support of the country’s Shiite clergy, sparking clashes with the religious right and others who resented his pro-West views.

“Secular programs” and the recognition of Israel caused the Islamic Revolution in Iran, CNN explains… of course, the world being that simple. It wasn’t rampant corruption amid wretched and rising wealth gaps. Nor the repression of dissidents. Nor the SAVAK. Not the Jansen-designed “tents” and lavish menu to celebrate 2,500 years of Persian history at a cost of $200 million for the world’s royalty. And certainly not the guile and appeal of Khomenei. History is the first thing axed in media, and the world should be an easily composed picture on CNN.

Nikki Keddie’s book for one offers better explanations.

Filed under: Iran, Media , ,

‘Like a war zone’

31

Bloody clashes broke out in Tehran yesterday as Iran’s supreme leader said he would not yield to pressure over the disputed election. The renewed confrontation took place in Baharestan Square, near parliament, where hundreds of protesters faced off against several thousand riot police and other security personnel.

Witnesses likened the scene to a ­war zone, with helicopters hovering overhead, many arrests and the police beating demonstrators.

One woman told CNN that hundreds of unidentified men armed with clubs had emerged from a mosque to confront the protesters.

“They beat a woman so savagely that she was drenched in blood and her husband fainted. They were beating people like hell. It was a massacre,” she said.

From the Guardian. Photo near Azadi Square in Tehran on 20 June, 6pm, from Tehran Bureau.

Filed under: Iran, Media ,

Iran

5064_1100528746971_1039230588_30255313_2519720_nVia Ami Kumar.

Filed under: Iran , ,

2509LD1

From Reza Aslan at The Daily Beast again. Photo from the Economist.

Khamenei was chosen to succeed Khomeini because he was considered a safe bet, someone who would not rock the boat, someone who could be easily controlled by more powerful, more charismatic figures who chaired the various clerical subcommittees, like his fellow revolutionary Hashemi Rafsanjani (now an ayatollah himself), who was instrumental in Khamenei’s selection to the post of supreme leader.

Devoid of Khomeini’s charisma and his religious credentials, Khamenei dropped into the background. Throughout his term as faqih, he has consistently played the role of neutral interlocutor among the competing poles of power in Iran, always strenuously portraying himself as the above the fray of common politics. This hands-off approach resulted in the gradual diffusion of the faqih’s powers both to the subcommittees beneath him and, more disastrously, to the state’s military-intelligence apparatus, the Revolutionary Guard, which has become arguably the most powerful force in Iranian politics (see my piece on how the stolen elections represent a military coup by the Revolutionary Guard). At the same time, the ranks of junior clergy studying in Iran’s seminaries have begun increasingly to question the theological validity of the Valayat-e Faqih, especially now that Iraq’s more traditionally inclined (read: politically quiescent) clergy, headed by perhaps the senior-most ayatollah in the world, Ali al-Sistani, have become increasingly active in Iran.

Now it seems Khamenei wants his divine authority back. Yet by so enthusiastically—and, as even his confidants have admitted, inexplicably—inserting himself directly into the election controversy, he has destroyed his reputation as a “divinely guided arbiter.” Worse, by so forcefully backing the unpopular Ahmadinejad, he has tainted himself with an aura of corruption and scandal. In short, Khamenei has utterly, perhaps irreparably, damaged the office of supreme leader. That is why the very people who helped put him in power 20 years ago are now trying to get rid of him. (As I write this, Ayatollah Rafsanjani is currently in Qom trying to garner support from his fellow Assembly of Expert members to remove Khamenei from power.)

Filed under: Iran, Media , , , ,

“wear all black to honor those killed everyday here!”

Facebook status of a friend in Tehran. Alternatively from Iranians outside the country: “WEAR ALL BLACK TO HONOR THOSE KILLED EVERYDAY IN IRAN!”

Filed under: Iran , , ,

The police and the basiji

pg-4-protest-main-a_188702s

Robert Fisk was in north Tehran last night:

The fate of Iran rested last night in a grubby north Tehran highway interchange called Vanak Square where – after days of violence – supporters of the official President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad at last confronted the screaming, angry Iranians who have decided that Mirhossein Mousavi should be the president of their country. Unbelievably – and I am a witness because I stood beside them – just 400 Iranian special forces police were keeping these two armies apart. There were stones and tear gas but for the first time in this epic crisis the cops promised to protect both sides.

“Please, please, keep the Basiji from us,” one middle-aged lady pleaded with a special forces officer in flak jacket and helmet as the Islamic Republic’s thug-like militia appeared in their camouflage trousers and purity-white shirts only a few metres away. The cop smiled at her. “With God’s help,” he said. Two other policemen were lifted shoulder-high. “Tashakor, tashakor,” – “thank you, thank you” – the crowd roared at them.

This was phenomenal. The armed special forces of the Islamic Republic, hitherto always allies of the Basiji, were prepared for once, it seemed, to protect all Iranians, not just Ahmadinejad’s henchmen. The precedent for this sudden neutrality is known to everyone – it was when the Shah’s army refused to fire on the millions of demonstrators demanding his overthrow in 1979.

More of the story, and more photos from the Independent.

Filed under: Iran, Media , , ,

Votes cast abroad favor Moussavi

Press TV has obtained the Interior Ministry’s detailed list of the votes cast abroad in the country’s 10th presidential election held on Friday, June 12.

A total of 234,812 votes were cast outside Iran, out of which Mahmoud Ahmadinejad won 78,300; Mehdi Karroubi won 4,647; Mohsen Rezaei won 3,635 and Mir-Hossein Moussavi won 111,792 votes.

Get all the numbers here.  Interesting the note the breakdown in Damascus:

Damascus

Total votes: 10,378
Mahmoud Ahmadinejad: 7,184
Mehdi Karroubi: 60
Mohsen Rezaei: 153
Mir-Hossein Moussavi: 2,866


Filed under: Iran, Media, Syria , , , ,

The Novelist in Wartime

storyThanks to the ‘onceuponthenile’ GoogleGroup that daily floods my inbox with links and stories from Chelsey, Hanna and Paul, I just read this speech by Haruki Murakami given in Jerusalem in February. He was accepting the Jerusalem Prize.

Feb. 20, 2009 | I have come to Jerusalem today as a novelist, which is to say as a professional spinner of lies.

Of course, novelists are not the only ones who tell lies. Politicians do it, too, as we all know. Diplomats and military men tell their own kinds of lies on occasion, as do used car salesmen, butchers and builders. The lies of novelists differ from others, however, in that no one criticizes the novelist as immoral for telling lies. Indeed, the bigger and better his lies and the more ingeniously he creates them, the more he is likely to be praised by the public and the critics. Why should that be?

My answer would be this: Namely, that by telling skillful lies — which is to say, by making up fictions that appear to be true — the novelist can bring a truth out to a new location and shine a new light on it. In most cases, it is virtually impossible to grasp a truth in its original form and depict it accurately. This is why we try to grab its tail by luring the truth from its hiding place, transferring it to a fictional location, and replacing it with a fictional form. In order to accomplish this, however, we first have to clarify where the truth lies within us. This is an important qualification for making up good lies.

Today, however, I have no intention of lying. I will try to be as honest as I can. There are a few days in the year when I do not engage in telling lies, and today happens to be one of them.

More.

Filed under: Israel/Palestine, Literature , , ,

A Military Coup

28656980

So let’s get this straight. We are supposed to believe that Mahmoud Ahmadinejad was reelected in Iran’s presidential election last week by a 2 to 1 margin against his reformist rival Mir Hossein Mousavi. That this deeply unpopular president, whose gross mismanagement of the state budget is widely blamed for Iran’s economy hovering on the edge of total collapse, received approximately the same percentage of votes as Mohammad Khatami, by far Iran’s most popular past president, received in both 1997 and 2001? That Mousavi, whom all independent polls predicted would at the very least take Ahmadinejad into a run-off election, lost not only his main base of support, Tehran, but also his own hometown of Khameneh in East Azerbaijan (which, as any Azeri will tell you, never votes for anyone but its own native sons)…and by a landslide. That we should all take the word of the Interior Ministry, led by a man put in his position by Ahmadinejad himself, a man who called the election for the incumbent before the polls were even officially closed, that the election was a fair representation of the will of the Iranian people.

Bullshit.

Reza Aslan at The Daily Beast. Photo from the AP of Monday’’s protest in Tehran, from Azadi Square.

Filed under: Iran , , , ,

Tehran reports

A good friend is writing and living in Tehran. He has started sending regular dispatches, what he calls a “personal, subjective daily tehran report.” With the surface-scratching of Western reporters and the limits of coverage in general, these personal reports become more vital.

The first Tehran report.

The second Tehran report.

Filed under: Iran , , , ,

From Tehran

This was forwarded by a friend. The photo mentioned is from this YouTube video:

a political coup is happening in Iran

the person in white shirt is my friend,***, student of sculpture at Tehran University, School of fine arts. I was chatting with him hour ago on yahoo messenger, he was inside Tehran University Dormitory. he said he had hid himself under the bed but he could hear screams and shouts. he told me there is blood everywhere and police are finally gone. the students had taken some of the militia’s captive and they were holding them inside the library. the police storms the library and arrests everyone. the number of injuries and arrests is unknown. this happened at the night of june 14 2009 after midnight. earlier in the evening, this video was recorded inside tehran university school of fine arts. in this video Rahnavard urges student to non violent protest and promise them that her husband would not give up. hours later the police attack univeristy too. some of the people you see in the video incuding girls are missing at the moment. People inside Iran are in media boycott and reporters of westeren media are unfortunately being deported from Iran because their visa’s have expired. please spread the word and let the world know what is happening in Iran these days.

Filed under: Uncategorized , , , , , ,

‘Bill Clinton is Syrian’ and other tales of Obama’s speech from Damascus

The traffic flowed through Damascus last Thursday, peaking as always in the early afternoon. There was little buzz about President Obama in Cairo, and given all the packed taxis and microbuses clogging the street, it was a typical day in Damascus – and no special arrangements to watch the speech.

“Of course I know,” taxi driver Adnan replied when asked about Obama’s visit to Cairo University. “He was in Saudi yesterday.”

The oil-rich kingdom is hardly popular here, owing to its mass accumulation of crude cash, its support for Sunni fundamentalism, and its closeness with America.

“Obama goes to Saudi, he goes to Egypt. He goes to Turkey and soon enough he’ll go to Israel,” Adnan complained. “But he doesn’t come here.”

Before an American ambassador returns to Damascus, before US sanctions are lifted, average Syrians will likely continue to ignore gestures of American oratory and reconciliation.

More of my recent HuffPost.

.

Filed under: America, Egypt, Israel/Palestine, Syria, Writing , , , ,

Clocking 2KM around Syria

Barreling near the Jebel Ansariyya that separate Syria’s coast from its rich interior, we stopped to ask for directions.

“Peace be upon you! Sir, is this the road to al-Ghab, to Apamea?” The man on the motorcycle stopped, shook his head, but said to follow him. “Up this mountain, my friends, is the shrine of Job.”

Being lost in a rental car in Syria has its benefits. Hours earlier, we were driving beside olive and almond groves that grew over beds of magenta wild flowers. Days before that we pulled into the Sumerian ruins of Mari, the site of a vast and preserved mud-brick pleasure palace of a ruler named Zimri-Lim, circa 1700 BC. Just upstream on the Euphrates is the Greek-Roman garrison town of Dura Europos, whose high ramparts look down on the river as it flows south to Iraq.

Such a miscellany of sights, among them pushing into a carnival Palm Sunday service at a Syriac church in the Kurdish northeast, is the gift of car travel – and of an odometer clocking two thousand kilometers over four days.

In a counterclockwise loop mimicking the shape of Syria, our Kia began by speeding to and from the Euphrates and the desert that creeps around it. From the Kurdish northeast we drove west to the yawning cisterns below Rasafa, a walled, mud-brick desert community where they worshipped St. Sergius, with enough time to see the sun set on the artificial lake of Hafez al-Assad. The watery mass was made in the 1970s by damming the fabled Furat.

The next day, after visits to the abandoned Byzantine towns of Serjilla and al-Bara, we stumbled upon Job’s shrine thanks to our motorcycle guide. He introduced himself at the top of Jebel Zawiyya as the local imam, though we could have guessed from his faultless fusha. Job’s shrine was a simple stone structure topped with tilting dome painted green. An olive tree grew behind it and next door was an unfortunate military building, large antennas shooting into the sky and casting shadows over the sanctum.

We descended into the Ghab, a rich valley that was a swamp before IMF money restored irrigation canals from the Orontes River and produced a lake.

We stopped to buy olive oil, hoping to find a man who would sell us anything less than a barrel. Lingering for tea with two plastic bottles of zeit zeitun, we drew a crowd of fifteen – mostly bright-eyed kids – as we talked with the local imam, Mohammed Ali. We asked him the name of his village.

“Qalat ad-Deen,” he smiled to us. Fortress of Faith.

“What benefit do you get from visiting ancient ruins?” he asked in return. Two of us cited our university studies in Middle Eastern history and classical Arabic literature and their connection to Syria’s richness of archaeological sites. Mohammed Ali nodded, and insisted we stay for the night.

More and more tourists are coming to Syria to see a country beyond the headlines and a camp Axis of Evil tag. Its richness of history, food and hospitality are quickly apparent on the limited visitors’ route: a few days in Damascus’ Old City; time in Aleppo’s covered Suq; the sunset and sunrise over the colonnades and temples at the ancient desert city of Palmyra.

A rental car is more promising. It allows you to speed to corners of the country that see less visitors and to talk to people along the way, even if those conversations involve flat tires and a stream of police questions at the hostel desk about where you’re coming from and where you’re going next.

In Hassakeh in the Kurdish northeast, the interrogation at the Ugarit Hotel went like this:

“Where are you coming from? Damascus? Deir az-Zur? When did you leave? But it’s a three hours drive here. You drove south first? To ruins? But there are ruins in Tadmur, you know? So what time did you leave Deir again? And you live in Damascus? How many days do you have the car for? When are you going back? What time are you leaving tomorrow? Going where? Aleppo? And then where? Welcome. How are you?”

An old white Peugot 504 followed us out of Hassakeh after our visit to the town’s Syriac church – a sign of the government’s tight monitoring of Kurds, a majority of whom cannot vote in Syria, and of foreigners who decide to visit their corner of the country.

The police did a bad job of hiding surveillance, but they pulled away when we took the turn for Aleppo and not for Qamishle, a Kurdish town on the Turkish border. Sure enough down the highway, at the only checkpoint we passed through in all of Syria, a man with a Kalashnikov was smiling knowingly, waiting to check our passports.

On the desert road to Deir az-Zur beyond Palymra the Kia got a flat tire that wouldn’t bulge from the wheel. A packed motorcycle approached, putting down the highway. We flagged it and when it stopped, a man in a red headscarf hopped off, walked past us without a word and started off into the desert. The bike’s driver responded to our greetings and deftly detached the wheel, screwed on the spare, and left without saying much. We saw him a hundred meters down off the highway after picking up his friend walking in the hard sand.

A party of Iraqis from Mosul helped us next. Their stone house on the side of the highway was not a proper garage stocking new tires, as hoped. They suggested we rotate the tires, putting the spare at the rear. The oldest man among them, Ghazzi, with fair skin, a thick moustache and a worn jalabiyya, said we shouldn’t pay more than a 1000 Syrian pounds (about 21 dollars) for a new one in Deir az-Zur. We had tea, as usual, and they asked what we doing out in the desert.

Filed under: Syria, Writing , , , , ,

American-made death squads

Another side of the American remaking of Iraq, from the Nation:

As Hassan tells it, it was a quiet night on June 10, 2008, in Sadr City, Baghdad’s poor Shiite district of more than 2 million people, when the helicopter appeared over his house and the front door exploded, nearly burning his sleeping youngest son. Before Hassan knew it, he was on the ground, hands bound and a bag over his head, with eight men pointing rifles at him, locked and loaded.

At first he couldn’t tell whether the men were Iraqis or Americans. He says he identified himself as a police sergeant, offering his ID before they took his pistol and knocked him to the ground. The men didn’t move like any Iraqi forces he’d ever seen. They looked and spoke like his countrymen, but they were wearing American-style uniforms and carrying American weapons with night-vision scopes. They accused him of being a commander in the local militia, the Mahdi Army, before they dragged him off, telling his wife he was “finished.” But before they left, they identified themselves. “We are the Special Forces. The dirty brigade,” Hassan recalls them saying.

The Iraq Special Operations Forces (ISOF) is probably the largest special forces outfit ever built by the United States, and it is free of many of the controls that most governments employ to rein in such lethal forces. The project started in the deserts of Jordan just after the Americans took Baghdad in April 2003. There, the US Army’s Special Forces, or Green Berets, trained mostly 18-year-old Iraqis with no prior military experience. The resulting brigade was a Green Beret’s dream come true: a deadly, elite, covert unit, fully fitted with American equipment, that would operate for years under US command and be unaccountable to Iraqi ministries and the normal political process.

More.

Filed under: America, Iraq, Media , , , ,

Better reactions to Obama

Sifting through all the reaction pieces — and posting here for the first time in a while — I found this op-ed by Egyptian novelist Ahdaf Soueif

The Egyptian state is doing pomp, and relieved (because of the security lockdown) of traffic and noise Cairo is playing along: the morning light is clear and free of dust, the flame trees are magnificent with their crowns of red massed flowers.

Writers life Soueif often make the best commentators:

Obama did what many of us hoped he would not do: he accorded faith a central position in the relationship between our different parts of the world: rather than human beings with different histories and different political interests and ambitions – and despite a quick acknowledgment of colonialism – we were essentially people of different faiths who would now make nice with each other. And such is our beleaguered state of mind here in this part of the world that every time he quoted the Qur’an, he was applauded. But then again, it seemed that it was the same 200 or so people who were putting their hands together – to less effect each time.

Also on the Guardian’s website was this op-ed by Ali Abuminah. Cheers for the British press. 

Once you strip away the mujamalat – the courtesies exchanged between guest and host – the substance of President Obama’s speech in Cairo indicates there is likely to be little real change in US policy. It is not necessary to divine Obama’s intentions – he may be utterly sincere and I believe he is. It is his analysis and prescriptions that in most regards maintain flawed American policies intact….

… Nowhere were these blindspots more apparent than his statements about Palestine/Israel. He gave his audience a detailed lesson on the Holocaust and explicitly used it as a justification for the creation of Israel. “It is also undeniable,” the president said, “that the Palestinian people – Muslims and Christians – have suffered in pursuit of a homeland. For more than sixty years they have endured the pain of dislocation.”

Suffered in pursuit of a homeland? The pain of dislocation? They already had a homeland. They suffered from being ethnically cleansed and dispossessed of it and prevented from returning on the grounds that they are from the wrong ethno-national group. Why is that still so hard to say?

Filed under: America, Israel/Palestine, Media , , , , ,

About

My Flickr

AUC

AUC library

AUC

Cairo

Taybeh Oktoberfest

Yasser Arafat's tomb

More Photos

 

June 2009
M T W T F S S
« May   Jul »
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930  

Archives